01
Benjamin Moore original
A project where the named Benjamin Moore colour is the specification and preserving that manufacturer, colour code, paint line, and sheen matters more than changing the buying route.
Cross-brand colour matching
Sherwin-Williams color match vs Benjamin Moore original
Can Sherwin-Williams color match Benjamin Moore? It can make or identify a nearby colour, but that result is a new formula, not the Benjamin Moore original. Compare both dried samples before you buy gallons.
See your colours in your room
One free render. No signup or card required.
A real TestMyPaint render, measured against the requested colour code.
The short answer
Use the Benjamin Moore original when that exact code is the specification. Use a Sherwin-Williams closest match only when its product or store path matters and the dried sample passes in your room.
Start with what you need to decide
One path preserves the original manufacturer formula. The other creates a nearby Sherwin-Williams result that needs its own physical approval.
02
Sherwin-Williams closest match
A project that needs to move into a Sherwin-Williams product and store path, while accepting that the result is a new formula that must be approved on its own.
Compare the practical details
Facts checked 17 August 2026
What you receive
Benjamin Moore original
You buy the named Benjamin Moore colour in a Benjamin Moore paint through a participating independent retailer. The colour code, product, base, and sheen stay inside one manufacturer system.
Sherwin-Williams closest match
A Sherwin-Williams store can help identify or formulate a nearby option. Its ColorSnap Match Pro tool scans a surface and returns the closest available Sherwin-Williams colour and sheen result.
How colour is chosen
Benjamin Moore original
Start from the Benjamin Moore name and code rather than a phone photo or screen sample. Benjamin Moore says its proprietary colourant and paint formula cannot be replicated exactly in another paint brand.
Sherwin-Williams closest match
Use a clean physical sample or stable painted surface when possible. Sherwin-Williams says phone cameras cannot control shadows, sunlight, and camera differences in the way a dedicated scanner can.
What can shift
Benjamin Moore original
The dried result can still shift with the selected Benjamin Moore product, base, sheen, substrate, preparation, application, and room light. A digital preview is only a shortlist aid.
Sherwin-Williams closest match
Closest does not mean identical. The Sherwin-Williams paint, base, pigments, colourants, sheen, and application can differ from the Benjamin Moore original even when the sample looks close under one light.
Best proof
Benjamin Moore original
Order a physical sample of the exact Benjamin Moore colour, label it with the product and sheen, and judge it beside the room's flooring, trim, furniture, and fixed materials in changing light.
Sherwin-Williams closest match
Ask for the exact Sherwin-Williams formula and product, then test that physical sample beside the Benjamin Moore sample. Compare both after drying under daylight and the artificial light used in the room.
Choose it when
Benjamin Moore original
Choose the original when a designer, homeowner, touch-up record, or existing project specifies the Benjamin Moore code and an exact cross-brand substitute is not worth the uncertainty.
Sherwin-Williams closest match
Choose the closest match when the Sherwin-Williams product or store route is a real requirement and the actual dried sample passes in the room, not because a cross-reference or screen says it should.
Decision guide
How to compare an original with a cross-brand match
Keep the reference physical, label the complete formulas, and make the final call after both samples dry in the room.
01
Treat a cross-brand match as a new colour decision
The useful question is not whether a store can make a colour with the same familiar name. It is whether the new formula looks close enough for this room and project. Benjamin Moore states that its paint and proprietary colourant system cannot be reproduced exactly in another brand. Sherwin-Williams describes its matching device as finding the closest available Sherwin-Williams colour. Those claims point to the same practical boundary: a match can be useful without being the original. Record the source colour, the matched formula, the paint line, the base, and the sheen as two separate specifications. If the Benjamin Moore code is contractually or aesthetically fixed, keep the original. If changing manufacturers is required, approve the Sherwin-Williams result as a fresh sample rather than assuming equivalence from a database or label.
02
Bring a physical reference, not a screenshot
A screenshot, listing photo, or phone capture is a weak matching reference because the display, camera processing, white balance, shadows, and compression can all change colour. Sherwin-Williams explains that phone cameras vary and cannot control external light in the way its dedicated ColorSnap Match Pro scanner does. Bring a clean, flat physical sample when you can: an original colour chip, a removable sample, or a stable piece of the painted surface. Avoid dusty, faded, stained, glossy, textured, or sun-damaged areas if they do not represent the finish you want to reproduce. If the old wall is the only reference, take the sample from an inconspicuous area and tell the store what it is. Matching the aged wall and matching the original Benjamin Moore code are different jobs.
03
Keep colour, product, base, and sheen together
A colour formula does not exist independently of the coating that carries it. The Benjamin Moore original combines a named colour with a Benjamin Moore product, base, and sheen. A Sherwin-Williams match places a different formula inside a Sherwin-Williams product system. Sheen changes reflected light, while the base, substrate, film thickness, and application affect how the dried colour reads. That is why a close fan-deck result can still separate on the wall. Write the full specification on every sample and do not compare an eggshell original with a satin match as if colour were the only variable. When possible, choose products intended for the same surface and room conditions. The goal is not a laboratory claim of sameness. It is a controlled enough comparison to decide whether the visible difference matters in the finished room.
04
Preview the direction before paying for two samples
Use TestMyPaint when you still need to decide whether the room works with the intended colour direction. Enter the colour code or choose a source-checked manufacturer colour, then compare it on the same room photo with the floor, trim, furniture, and daylight held in view. The result reports the requested code and measured Delta E, which helps show how closely the rendered colour landed. It does not prove that one manufacturer's dried paint will match another, and it cannot reproduce sheen or guarantee perfect wall targeting. Paint can spill into nearby areas, dark photos are less reliable, and generated details can change. Reject any render with obvious artefacts. Use the preview to remove a poor direction, then spend the physical-sample step on the formulas you might actually buy.
05
Compare both dried samples in the actual room
Put the Benjamin Moore original and the Sherwin-Williams match beside each other on movable sample boards or on prepared test areas, following each product's directions. Let them dry and cure for the period the manufacturer specifies before making the final judgement. Check the samples on more than one wall and beside the fixed materials that matter. Morning daylight, evening daylight, warm lamps, cool task lighting, and deep shadow can reveal differences that disappear at the paint counter. Look for changes in undertone, lightness, saturation, and sheen rather than asking only whether the colours feel close. If they will meet on the same plane or a touch-up must disappear, small differences matter more. If they sit in separate rooms, a close visual relationship may be enough.
06
Know when the original is the safer answer
Use the Benjamin Moore original when the exact named colour is part of a designer specification, when new paint must blend into an existing Benjamin Moore wall, or when you do not have time to test and approve a substitute. Consider the Sherwin-Williams match when the contractor, local supply path, required coating, or account makes that manufacturer materially easier to use. Even then, keep the decision conditional on the dried sample. Neither a scanner result nor a cross-reference chart guarantees an invisible touch-up or an identical room. If the samples separate in the room and the original colour still matters, buy the original. If the difference is acceptable and the Sherwin-Williams system solves a real project need, document the approved formula so later gallons and touch-ups use the same specification.
Where TestMyPaint fits
Compare a shortlist by the colour actually delivered
TestMyPaint runs in a browser and accepts a room photo. Choose from 48 curated colours, enter a custom hex, or use the Paint brands selector, which includes 1,532 source-checked colours across eight US and Canadian manufacturer catalogues. Signed-in visitors can compare up to five options, and every result shows the requested code and a measured Delta E colour difference.
Live augmented reality is not included, UK and Australian catalogues are still in preparation, and wall targeting can still miss. Use it to narrow the shortlist, then confirm the finalist with a physical swatch.
Common questions
Benjamin Moore original vs Sherwin-Williams closest match FAQ
Can Sherwin-Williams color match Benjamin Moore?
Sherwin-Williams can identify or formulate a nearby colour, but treat it as a closest match rather than the Benjamin Moore original. The paint, base, pigments, colourants, and sheen can differ. Compare a dried sample of the actual Sherwin-Williams formula with the exact Benjamin Moore sample in the room before buying gallons.
Will the same paint colour code look identical across brands?
No code alone guarantees an identical result across manufacturers. Each brand uses its own products, bases, colourants, and formulas, and sheen changes reflected light. Record the manufacturer, colour name, code, product, base, and sheen together, then judge dried samples under the room's real light.
Should I bring a Benjamin Moore chip or a photo to Sherwin-Williams?
Bring a clean physical reference when possible. A colour chip, removable sample, or stable piece of the painted surface avoids some of the camera, screen, shadow, and white-balance changes in a phone photo. Explain whether you want the original code or the appearance of an aged wall, because those are different targets.
Can a paint visualizer prove that two brand colours match?
No. A room-photo visualizer helps compare colour direction beside the floor, trim, and furniture, but it cannot reproduce two cured paint formulas or their sheen. Use TestMyPaint to narrow the direction, then compare physical samples of the exact Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams products you may buy.
When should I keep the Benjamin Moore original?
Keep the original when the Benjamin Moore code is specified, when a touch-up must blend into an existing wall, or when you cannot test a substitute. A Sherwin-Williams closest match can be practical when its product or store route matters, but approve that dried formula as a separate colour decision.
Keep narrowing
Related paint guides
Continue with the question closest to your room before you buy a sample.
Sources and notes
Public product information checked 17 August 2026. Features and availability can change.
Benjamin Moore original: Benjamin Moore FAQ
Sherwin-Williams closest match: Sherwin-Williams ColorSnap Match Pro FAQ
Sherwin-Williams ColorSnap Match Pro
Sherwin-Williams paint samples
This comparison uses published product information, not a controlled hands-on test. Screen previews cannot replace a physical swatch in the room's real light.